Synology RAID calculator: estimate usable storage

Share
A Synology NAS with several hard drives sitting on a desk.

A Synology RAID calculator tells you how much usable space you’ll actually get after redundancy is built in. The number on the drive box is raw capacity; the number that matters is the protected space you can store data on. The same set of drives can give you very different usable results depending on whether you choose RAID, SHR, or mirroring. If you’re planning a NAS buy, start with the drive sizes you already have in mind and check them against the Synology mode you want. Four 4 TB drives give you 16 TB raw, but the usable space is lower because some of that capacity is reserved for protection.

What the calculator is trying to tell you

The calculator’s job is to turn raw drive capacity into usable storage after protection is applied. Raw capacity is just the sum of the drive labels. Usable capacity is what remains after the array reserves space to survive a drive failure.

Say you have four 4 TB drives. Raw capacity is 16 TB. If you use a single-drive fault-tolerant layout such as RAID 5 or SHR-1, one drive’s worth of capacity is used for parity or equivalent protection, so the usable space is roughly 12 TB before formatting and filesystem overhead. If you choose a mirrored layout such as RAID 1, the usable amount is much lower because the same data is written to multiple drives.

That’s the main point of a Synology calculator: it shows how much of your raw drive total turns into protected storage, so you can compare layouts before you buy hardware.

Enter your drive sizes and pick the right Synology mode

Start by listing every drive you plan to install, including mixed sizes. Count the bays, note each drive label, and decide whether you want RAID 1, 5, 6, 10, or SHR. If you are mixing capacities, that choice matters a lot.

For a calculator, the inputs are usually simple:

  • number of drives
  • size of each drive
  • RAID level or SHR mode
  • whether any bay is reserved as a hot spare

Pick the mode that matches how you plan to configure Storage Manager. RAID 1 mirrors data across drives, RAID 5 uses one-drive parity, RAID 6 uses two-drive parity, and RAID 10 combines mirroring and striping. SHR behaves more flexibly with mismatched drive sizes, but it still follows the same basic idea of trading some raw space for fault tolerance.

If you already know you want expansion later, include that in the plan before you buy. A calculator can show the current usable size, but it can only estimate future growth if you know what drives you expect to add later.

A Synology NAS shows open drive bays with mixed-size drives installed.

How to read the usable space number

Treat the calculator’s result as protected pool capacity, not the exact number DSM will show as free space on day one. There are usually three figures to keep apart: raw capacity, protected capacity, and formatted volume size.

Raw capacity is the label sum. Protected capacity is what remains after parity or mirroring. The number DSM shows after you create the storage pool or volume is usually a bit smaller again, because the filesystem needs room for metadata and housekeeping.

That’s why a “4 TB” drive never appears as a full 4 TB in DSM. Drive makers use decimal terabytes, while operating systems report in a different way, and then Synology also sets aside space for the array and filesystem. So if a calculator tells you 12 TB usable from four 4 TB drives in RAID 5 or SHR-1, expect the visible formatted volume to come in a little under that figure.

Use the calculator for planning, not as a promise of the exact free-space number you’ll see later.

Why SHR often gives a better result with mixed drives

SHR is usually the better fit when your drive sizes do not match, because it can use uneven disks more efficiently than classic RAID in many home and small-office setups. The main reason is simple: classic RAID tends to treat all drives as if they were the same size, while SHR can build storage in a way that reuses the extra space on larger drives more intelligently.

Take a mix of 4 TB + 4 TB + 8 TB + 8 TB. With a classic RAID 5 layout, the array generally behaves as though each drive were limited by the smallest size, which means some of the extra capacity on the 8 TB drives goes unused. With SHR, the system can usually make better use of that extra space, so the usable total is often higher.

That does not mean SHR always beats every RAID choice. It means SHR is often the smarter default if you expect to buy drives in stages or use whatever sizes you already have. If all your drives match, SHR-1 and RAID 5 can end up very close in practical capacity.

Different-sized hard drives are lined up next to a Synology NAS.

Mixed drives, hot spares, and the difference between SHR-1 and SHR-2

Mixed drive sizes, hot spares, and the SHR level you choose all affect the final usable number. A hot spare is a drive that sits unused until another drive fails, so it reduces the capacity available to your array. If you reserve a bay for a hot spare, include that in the calculator; otherwise the result will be too optimistic.

SHR-1 and SHR-2 work differently in terms of fault tolerance. SHR-1 gives you one-drive protection, while SHR-2 gives you two-drive protection. That extra protection costs usable capacity, because more raw space is set aside for redundancy.

The same mixed set of drives can produce different results depending on which SHR mode you pick. With uneven sizes, SHR-1 is usually the capacity-friendly option. SHR-2 is the safer option when you want more breathing room during a rebuild or when losing a second drive would be especially painful.

If you are mixing sizes and thinking about expansion, check the layout you want before you buy. SHR can be more efficient than classic RAID with uneven drives, but the result still depends on the exact drive mix and the protection level you choose.

A spare hard drive sits next to a Synology NAS on a desk.

What can make the real number smaller than the calculator

The calculator usually stops at the array level, but the real usable space can still shrink a bit after setup. File-system overhead, snapshots, and reserved space all take a bite out of the final number.

A few common causes:

  • filesystem metadata and allocation overhead
  • snapshot reserve space if you enable snapshots
  • space held back by Synology for system use
  • volume formatting differences between the pool estimate and the mounted volume

That is why the storage pool size and the volume size are not always identical. The pool is the protected block of storage underneath; the volume is the formatted space DSM gives to shared folders and apps. If you enable more features later, the visible free space can drop even though the drive layout has not changed.

So when you compare a calculator result to DSM, allow for a gap. If the difference is small, that is normal.

When to choose SHR-1 instead of SHR-2

SHR-1 gives you better usable capacity, while SHR-2 gives you more fault tolerance. The tradeoff is straightforward: SHR-1 can usually survive one drive failure, and SHR-2 can usually survive two drive failures, depending on the layout and how the array is built.

Choose SHR-1 if you want the most space and your data can tolerate a short recovery window with good backups in place. That is a common choice for home use and many small offices. Choose SHR-2 if the data is more painful to lose, the array is large, or replacing failed drives would be slow enough that you want a second layer of protection.

The right answer is not just about the drives themselves. It also depends on how long you could live with a degraded array, how quickly you can replace failed hardware, and whether you have backups that you trust. SHR-2 costs you usable capacity, but it buys more breathing room if something goes wrong.

Prerquisites

  • A Synology NAS model with enough bays for the drive plan you want to check
  • The drive sizes you expect to install, including any mixed sizes
  • A decision about which mode you want to compare: RAID 1, 5, 6, 10, SHR-1, or SHR-2
  • A plan for whether one bay will be a hot spare or left empty
  • Access to Synology Storage Manager if you want to compare the calculator against DSM later

Steps

  1. List the drives you plan to use and write down each size.
  2. Decide which protection mode you want to compare in the Synology calculator.
  3. Include any hot spare in the plan before you calculate.
  4. Check the result against your real storage goal, not just the largest number on the screen.
  5. If you are mixing drive sizes, compare SHR with the classic RAID levels before you buy.
  6. If you want more protection, compare SHR-1 and SHR-2 and note the capacity tradeoff.
  7. Leave room in your plan for formatting overhead, snapshots, and the fact that DSM will show less than the raw label size.

Completion

You’ve got the right result when the calculator output matches the RAID or SHR layout you actually plan to build, including mixed drive sizes and any hot spare. The usable number should make sense after you subtract some space for formatting, snapshots, and other DSM overhead.

If the plan still looks good after that check, you’re ready to buy drives with a realistic capacity target in mind.

A quick sanity check before you order drives

Before you buy, run the plan through one final check. Make sure the calculator result matches the mode you really want, not just the mode that looks biggest on paper.

Use this checklist:

  • confirm the exact bay count in your Synology model
  • confirm each drive size you plan to install
  • decide now between RAID 1, 5, 6, 10, SHR-1, or SHR-2
  • check whether one bay will be a hot spare or kept empty
  • think about future expansion, not just day-one capacity
  • verify that the drives are compatible with your model and firmware plan

If you expect to grow later, favor a layout that leaves room for it. A four-bay NAS filled all at once leaves less flexibility than a six- or eight-bay unit with open slots. The best calculator result is the one that still makes sense after you add more data, not just the one that looks largest today.

Conclusion

Once you know your drive mix and the RAID or SHR mode you want, a Synology RAID calculator becomes a planning tool rather than a guess. Use it to compare usable capacity, then subtract a little more in your head for formatting, snapshots, and other DSM overhead. If you are mixing drive sizes, SHR is usually the first layout to check. If you want more fault tolerance, compare SHR-1 and SHR-2 before you order anything. That small bit of planning now can save you from buying the wrong set of drives.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a Synology RAID calculator include formatting overhead?

Usually not in full detail. Most calculators show array-level usable capacity, but DSM still needs some space for filesystem metadata, system use, and volume formatting, so the final visible number is a bit smaller.

Is SHR always better than RAID?

Not always. SHR is often better with mixed drive sizes or staged upgrades, but with matching drives the usable result can be very close to classic RAID, and the better choice depends on how much fault tolerance you want.

Why does my 4 TB drive show less than 4 TB in DSM?

Because drive labels use decimal terabytes, DSM reports capacity differently, and the NAS also reserves space for array protection and filesystem overhead. Seeing less than the label size is normal.

Should I choose SHR-1 or SHR-2 for a small office?

If you want more usable space and you have solid backups, SHR-1 is often the default. If the data is harder to replace or the array is large enough that rebuild risk worries you, SHR-2 is the safer choice.